Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Walter's avatar

I think, ultimately, not so far in the future, the abortion question is resolved by technology. Someone develops an artificial womb, and someone else develops a procedure that can be had during the first trimester that moves the baby into it. The zillion dollar bill on the sidewalk is just too tempting.

At that point pro lifers 'win', so to speak, in that abortion becomes (give or take a generation and some edge cases that are never invoked) illegal, but they never 'win' in the sense that history will continue to regard them as the present regards them, as the antagonists of Very Special Episodes.

In the near term, I think that the repeal has a fairly muted outcome, in favor of pro choice politicians. It motives some people to vote who would not have otherwise bothered. This effect goes down over time as people experience the reality that the difference between the pre world of 'if you discover you are pregnant and need an abortion you go to a planned parenthood and get one' and the post world of 'if you discover you are pregnant and need an abortion you go to a planned parenthood in another state and get one' is far from the real world/mad max schism that it is being painted as.

I disagree about the idea that, in the longer term, people move between pro choice and pro life camps as the result of this. I hear you about the media, sympathy, etc, but it seems to me like those things were true yesterday as well. As far as evidence goes, all I've got is this, that If being the bad guys to the culture makers was going to persuade pro lifers and/or keep young people from joining them, their movement would have died sometime in the last 50 years.

Expand full comment
David Rensin's avatar

David R

just now

I think you’re absolutely correct. Thanks.

Among other factors, finally reframing gay marriage as marriage equality shifted focus and helped create change. Similarly maybe pro-choice could be reframed. “Pro” suggests there is a “con.” Maybe some revised and updated versions of the old standbys Family Planning or Planned Parenthood. Maybe Reproductive Health Equality. (I’m not good at this naming stuff so please chime in.)

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts